american seed reviews

Has anyone used ‘American Seed’ company’s seeds?

I was at Wal-mart today and saw a rack of seeds. I have been thinking about growing my own annuals from seed next year. Give me something to do while I impatiently wait for late spring. They had ‘American Seed’ brand and it was super cheap. But I’m wondering what the quality is like. I don’t see many reviews on the internet and I searched the forum and didn’t see anything. Just curious if anyone has used this brand and if they had decent success?


Last spring I bought seed for zuchinni and yellow squash, planted them, and lo and behold I have a garden full of pumpkins and watermelons.

  • Like | 3
  • Save
  • Newest
  • Oldest

Comments (16)


I tryed over 60 types of seeds this year, bought and ordered from many places. My conclusion is that I will not buy from the big stores and only order from Geoseed (no “s”).
Best germination, best prices and best people over the phone. But that’s just me. Bob

  • Like | 2
  • Save

I believe that you’ll find that the American seeds are about like almost all packaged seeds. Some germinate very well; some just seem to languish. Since they’er so inexpensive, just plant a few more seeds than you usually plant.

  • Like | 2
  • Save

Related Discussions

Kitchen sink – has anyone with a double sink wish for a single sink?

Has anyone installed LG Viatera Rococo?

Has anyone used a commerical grade engineered wood floor?

Flooring company lied, owner told us flooring was made in US


I’ve planted them and had no trouble at all. Just make sure you get fresh ones. But that’s true of any seeds. Freshest is best.

  • Like | 1
  • Save

My experience is that you don’t get many seeds, the varieties are quite common, and the germination rate varies widely from good to none germinating.

I’ve bought them for 10 cents a pack and you only need to get a couple to germinate for that price.

But with the time it takes and the cost of potting soil, etc, I’d rather have more reliable seeds and I’d rather have seeds for exactly the variety that I want.

I got some really nice zinnias from American Seeds this year. They all germinated and the plants are pretty. The cauliflower and kohlrabi from the same company had zero percent germination. I’ve grown tomatoes from their seeds and they were fine.

I’m not above picking up a packet of their seeds if I am walking by and see something that I have been looking for.

  • Like | 1
  • Save

I have used their seeds, and I have had good success with them. They are extremely cheap, but just as stated above they usually contain seeds that are very common. With that said I love those wildflower mixes, (I love daisies though) they have all kind of flowers in them which most are perennial. Some 2nd year bloomers some not. One year I got the most beautiful poppies out of a wildflower pack, and I didn’t save the seed and I have been unable to find anymore packs like that.

Another place I discovered that has some good seed variety is t’s online all seed packs are $1.00. I think shipping and handling for 19 packs is like $4.25 not bad if you ask me. I provided the link below, she has a great selection of seeds.

Here is a link that might be useful: T’s Seed Sale

I was at Wal-mart today and saw a rack of seeds. I have been thinking about growing my own annuals from seed next year. Give me something to do while I impatiently wait for late spring. They had 'American Seed' brand and it was super cheap. But I'm wondering what the quality is like. I don't see man…

Are seeds from Plantation Products (American Seed) any good

I have been very lucky with my purchases from American Seed Company. I have better germination than I get from other very reputable companies. My packages clearly state “Plantation Products”.

I know we have planted green beans, spinach and corn. Only corn was not a variety we liked. I have purchased lots of flower seeds from them. The price is much cheaper than the very reputable seed companies so I will continue to buy their seed.

When I do my research and decide what I want to purchase I look at them first, then look elsewhere for the things they don’t have available.

By all means use the seeds that you have!

“The Plantation Products Family of Brands Trusted by gardeners since 1850” “Plantation Products manages the most well-known seed and seed starting brands in North America. Many of these brands have been around since the mid-1800’s and have been trusted by generations of gardeners. Everyone at Plantation feels a deep sense of pride and responsibility to carry on the tradition of these brands by delivering the highest quality products to gardeners.”

Invasive plants are Earth’s way of insisting we notice her medicines. Stephen Herrod Buhner
Everyone learns what works by learning what doesn’t work. Stephen Herrod Buhner

I googled American Seed and found that these seeds are from a company called Plantation Products ( ) and they have a LOT of bad reviews. My question is, are these American Seeds from Walmart and Meijer type stores a rip off?